I realized that the Gifts Given page does not count multiple MKBs towards the value calculated at the bottom. I just put one more MKB under a friend's tree and the value did not even change by 1 sP. I had a feeling it didn't get calculated correctly so I decided to check this time. (I can also provide screenshots of it) It's not a huge problem, it is just kind of bugging me because if the value is shown at all it should at least be correct!

This seems to apply when yo give multiples of one item to the same user.

had you given an MKB to anyone else, already? Or to that friend, at least? I just gifted a friend with three of the same item. I had to do them one at a time, because the items were stacked, and it only added the value of the first one I put in. After I put in the second and third ones, my amount didn't go up. I'm wondering if stacks of items don't add up or something.

The only reason I noticed it is because these were the first gifts I have actually put under a tree (hey procrastination), so my value was 0 before I started :P

Ah, yeah, I have given that friend over 10 of those! I think the value was counted for the first time but so it might really be a problem with stacked items. All other items I have given were added to the value.

that must be it then :) I know there was a bug at first with stacks being deleted from the inventory when people tried to add one of an item under a tree, and Keith fixed that. Maybe that has something to do with why it's not 'counting' more than once towards the value.

Those things might have something to do with each other then! At least it sounds like a possibility! xD